COMMENTARY: Has the Electoral College outlived its usefulness?
“No!” The Electoral College was one of many foresighted policies that the Founding Fathers established though the U.S. Constitution.. How to choose a president through a delicate balance of the individual states and the federal government and between the Executive and Legislative branches of government was the challenge. The Founding Fathers answer was the Electoral College (Article II, Section 1 of the Constitution).
The winner take all approach encourages voter apathy, if that citizen is not supporting the “popular” candidate. The feeling that their vote will not count leads to a diminished interest in participating in the election process.
The problem is not with Electoral College, but with the implementation at the individual state level. Forty-eight states have adopted a winner take all approach for the awarding of the Electoral Votes. This is an individual state legislative decision. Only Maine and Nebraska have developed other plans which can allow for a split Electoral Vote.
This author suggests that the electoral delegates/votes be assigned by Proportional Representation of the popular vote within each state. Louisiana has eight Electoral votes. Under a Proportional Representation of the popular vote system for Louisiana’s electoral vote, the votes would be divided by percentage of vote, unless the candidate is represented by less than 10 percent of the popular vote. This would also allow for a meaningful representation of the popular vote.
In the November 2016 Presidential unofficial election results, Trump had 58.10 percent of the popular vote; Clinton had 38.44 percent; collectively all other candidates had 3.46 percent.
Trump would be awarded 60 percent of the electoral votes (4.8 of 8 = 5): 5 Electoral Votes and Clinton would be awarded 40 percent (3.2 of 8 = 3) : 3 Electoral Votes.
Using the Proportional Representation method allows for the voices of the citizens to be heard in a meaningful way in the choosing of our President. This is within the reach of all citizens, if they are willing to contact their State Legislators and ask that the law be changed on how Electoral Votes are awarded to Proportional Representation of the People.
The choice is up to US!
By Jean B. Armstrong, CPC, CED